Fundamentalism and Epistemic Authority
نویسنده
چکیده
I will discuss three questions in my paper: 1. What are the essential elements of fundamentalism? 2. What is the role of authority as a source of fundamentalism? 3. What is the role of trust in the spreading of fundamentalism? For each question I will outline a possible answer from a special theoretical point of view. What is " fundamentalism " ? There is an ongoing discussion about this question and many authors insist that fundamentalism is a distinctly present-day phenomenon and thus has to be understood as a reaction to modernity and its impositions (Almond/Appleby/Sivan 2003; Riese-brodt 2000). But the beliefs of contemporary fundamentalists reveal aspects which can be found throughout human history. I think that these general features are especially interesting and that they are connected with each other in a non-contingent way. Therefore I propose a wider characterization which not only encompasses modern phenomena but captures numerous varieties of fundamentalism. Accordingly three attributes are essential: 1. Fundamentalists propagate the supreme value of salvation-goods over worldly goods: for the ultimate fulfi lment of human existence it is important to overcome the obsession with mundane happiness and material utility and to strive instead for eternal redemption and ends which are more valuable than profane satisfaction in the life here and now. The supreme value of salvation-goods justifi es almost all sacrifi ces which are measured only by worldly criteria (Bernholz 2006). Salvation-goods must not necessarily be religious: to realize the mission of world history, the welfare of mankind or cosmic destiny can also gain supreme value in the sense of gaining lexicographic superiority over all inner-worldly aims. 2. Fundamentalists claim that their views are certain and that there is no room and necessity for doubt: an essential part of their thinking is their
منابع مشابه
Religious Fundamentalism Modulates Neural Responses to Error-Related Words: The Role of Motivation Toward Closure
Examining the relationship between brain activity and religious fundamentalism, this study explores whether fundamentalist religious beliefs increase responses to errorrelated words among participants intolerant to uncertainty (i.e., high in the need for closure) in comparison to those who have a high degree of toleration for uncertainty (i.e., those who are low in the need for closure). We exa...
متن کاملKnowledge, Moral Claims and the Exercise of Power in Global Health
A number of individuals and organizations have considerable influence over the selection of global health priorities and strategies. For some that influence derives from control over financial resources. For others it comes from expertise and claims to moral authority—what can be termed, respectively, epistemic and normative power. In contrast to financial power, we commonly take for granted th...
متن کاملNegotiating Epistemic Authority
Why do we trust what other people say, and form beliefs on the basis of their speech? One answer: they are taken to have epistemic authority. Intuitively this means that the other person (or institution, or group) is taken to be authoritative in what they say, at least with respect to a particular domain. Here, we want to claim that there are (at least) two varieties of epistemic authority, one...
متن کاملWhat Is An Expert That A Person May Trust Her?
I present a definition of expertise that involves both epistemic and political authority. I argue that these two forms of authority require different treatments and defend a political epistemology that articulates a division of cognitive labor between political and epistemic authority.
متن کاملA Corpus-based Analysis of Epistemic Stance Adverbs in Essays Written by Native English Speakers and Iranian EFL Learners
Academic essays entail taking a stance on the truth value of propositions. Epistemic adverbs deal with the speaker's assessment of the truth value of propositions. Employing a corpus-based approach with descriptive statistics and qualitative description, this study explored the use of epistemic stance adverbs in academic essays written by native English speakers and Iranian EFL learners. Follow...
متن کامل